Gonzalez & Waddington – Attorneys at Law

CALL NOW 1-800-921-8607

10 Most Commonly Asked Questions About Court Martials

10 Most Commonly Asked Questions About Court Martials

The article seeks to answer some of the most commonly asked questions about court-martials, the UCMJ, military lawyers, and military justice.

1. Who can be court-martialed?

10 Most Commonly Asked Questions About Court Martials military defense lawyersA court-martial is a military court that tries members of the armed forces for breaches of military law. Under the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ), several categories of individuals can be court-martialed.

First and foremost, active-duty service members in the Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps, and Coast Guard are subject to court-martial jurisdiction. This includes all enlisted personnel and officers. Reservists and National Guard members can also be court-martialed if they are on active duty or performing duties under federal orders.

Cadets and midshipmen at the U.S. Military Academy, Naval Academy, Air Force Academy, and Coast Guard Academy are also subject to the UCMJ and can be court-martialed.

Retired military personnel entitled to pay are another category under court-martial jurisdiction. Although they are no longer on active duty, retirees can be recalled to active duty for a court-martial.

Additionally, certain civilians can be court-martialed under specific circumstances. Civilians accompanying the armed forces in the field during wartime, such as contractors or dependents, can be subject to military law. Moreover, civilians employed by or accompanying the military overseas can fall under the UCMJ under certain conditions, especially during declared wars or contingency operations.

In times of declared war or a contingency operation, persons serving with or accompanying an armed force in the field can also be subject to court-martial. This includes contractors and other civilians who have direct involvement with military operations.

It’s important to note that the reach of court-martial jurisdiction over civilians is a subject of legal and constitutional scrutiny, and its application can be controversial. In most cases, civilian courts have jurisdiction over civilians, but the UCMJ provides specific provisions under which civilians can be tried by a court-martial.

2. What are the most common offenses tried at court-martials?

Court-martials in the military handle more severe offenses than those addressed through Non-Judicial Punishment (NJP). The most common offenses tried at court-martials include:

  1. Desertion: Leaving a duty station or military service without the intention of returning. This is a serious offense that indicates a complete abandonment of military duties.
  2. Drug Offenses: Use, possession, distribution, or trafficking of illegal drugs. The military maintains a strict zero-tolerance policy on drug abuse.
  3. Sexual Assault: Any non-consensual sexual act or behavior. The military takes allegations of sexual assault very seriously, with severe penalties for offenders.
  4. Larceny and Fraud: Theft of government or private property, and fraudulent activities such as submitting false claims or falsifying documents.
  5. Murder and Manslaughter: Unlawful killing of another person. These crimes are treated with utmost severity and carry significant penalties.
  6. Assault: Physical attacks against another person. This includes aggravated assault and assault with a deadly weapon.
  7. Adultery: Engaging in sexual relations with someone other than one’s spouse, particularly when it affects military order and discipline.
  8. Conduct Unbecoming an Officer: Behavior dishonoring or disgracing an officer. This is broadly defined and can include a variety of actions deemed inappropriate.
  9. AWOL (Absent Without Leave): Absence from one’s post without permission, especially if extended and without intent to return.
  10. Fraternization: Inappropriate relationships between service members of different ranks compromise the chain of command.
  11. Disrespect and Insubordination: Actions or words disrespecting a superior officer or refusing to obey lawful orders.

Court-martials are formal judicial proceedings that provide full legal protections to the accused, including the right to legal representation and a fair trial. The consequences of a court-martial conviction can be severe, including imprisonment, dishonorable discharge, and a permanent criminal record. These proceedings ensure serious offenses are addressed with the gravity they warrant, maintaining discipline and order within the military.

3. Can I choose to be court-martialed instead of facing non-judicial punishment (NJP)?

Yes, in most cases, a service member can choose to be court-martialed instead of facing Non-Judicial Punishment (NJP) under Article 15 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ). This choice depends on the branch of service and specific circumstances.

When a commander offers NJP, the service member is notified of the charges and the proposed punishment. At this stage, the service member has the right to request a court-martial instead of accepting NJP. This option is generally available to all service members except those attached to or embarked on a vessel. Service members on a vessel do not have the right to refuse NJP and must accept the commander’s decision.

Choosing a court-martial over NJP is a significant decision. A court-martial provides more procedural protections, including the right to a defense attorney, the right to present evidence and witnesses, and the right to a trial by a panel of military members or a judge. The accused can also cross-examine witnesses presented by the prosecution. However, the potential penalties from a court-martial are usually more severe than those from NJP, including confinement, a dishonorable discharge, and a federal conviction record.

The decision to request a court-martial should be made carefully, often in consultation with a military defense attorney. Factors to consider include the strength of the evidence, the severity of the alleged offense, and the possible consequences of a court-martial conviction.

In summary, while most service members have the right to request a court-martial instead of accepting NJP, this decision involves weighing the benefits of greater legal protections against the risks of more severe penalties. Legal advice is essential in making an informed choice.

4. How long does a court-martial typically last?

The duration of a court-martial can vary significantly depending on several factors, including the complexity of the case, the number of charges, the amount of evidence, and the availability of witnesses. Generally, court-martials can be categorized into three types: summary, special, and general court-martials, each with differing timelines.

  • Summary Court-Martial: This is the least formal and is typically reserved for minor offenses. It is usually presided over by a single officer and can be completed within a day or a few days. The procedures are expedited, and the accused has no right to a military judge or a jury.
  • Special Court-Martial: This is more formal than a summary court-martial and is akin to a civilian misdemeanor court. It usually involves a military judge and a panel of at least three service members. Special court-martials can last from a few days to a couple of weeks, depending on the complexity of the case and the number of witnesses called to testify.
  • General Court Martial: This is the most formal and is used for the most serious offenses, similar to a civilian felony court. It involves a military judge, a prosecutor, a defense counsel, and a panel of at least five service members. General court-martials can be lengthy, often lasting several weeks to several months. The duration is influenced by the number of charges, the volume of evidence, and the intricacies of the legal arguments presented.

In summary, while a summary court-martial can be resolved in a matter of days, a special and general court-martial can extend from a few weeks to several months. The complexity of the case and procedural requirements are the primary determinants of the duration.

5. What are the possible consequences of a court-martial conviction?

A court-martial conviction can have significant and far-reaching consequences for military personnel. These consequences vary based on the type of court-martial (summary, special, or general) and the severity of the offense but generally include:

  1. Criminal Record: A court-martial conviction results in a federal criminal record, which can affect future employment, security clearances, and civil rights, such as the right to vote or possess firearms.
  2. Punitive Discharge: Convicted service members may receive a punitive discharge, such as a Bad Conduct Discharge (BCD) or Dishonorable Discharge (DD). These discharges are noted on the service member’s record and can lead to a loss of veterans’ benefits, including healthcare, education, and housing assistance.
  3. Imprisonment: Depending on the offense, a court-martial can impose a sentence of confinement. The length of imprisonment varies, with general court-martial sentences often being more severe.
  4. Reduction in Rank: Conviction may result in a reduction in rank, stripping the service member of any achieved rank and its associated pay and responsibilities.
  5. Forfeiture of Pay and Allowances: The convicted individual may be required to forfeit all or part of their pay and allowances, significantly impacting their financial situation.
  6. Fines: In some cases, the court-martial may impose a monetary fine as part of the sentence.
  7. Reputation and Future Opportunities: A court-martial conviction can severely damage a service member’s reputation and career prospects both within the military and in civilian life. It can make securing future employment, particularly in fields requiring security clearances or positions of trust, very difficult.
  8. Collateral Consequences: Beyond the immediate penalties, there are numerous collateral consequences, such as loss of military honors, eligibility for government benefits, and social stigma associated with a criminal conviction and punitive discharge.
  9. Sex-offender Registration: Sex offender registration mandates convicted individuals to submit personal information to a national registry, including their name, address, employment, and vehicles. They must regularly update this information and report changes. The registry, often public, allows community access to local offender details, aiming to enhance safety and prevent reoffending. Registration duration varies by crime severity and jurisdiction, from a few years to life. Non-compliance can lead to further criminal charges and penalties.

In summary, the consequences of a court-martial conviction are comprehensive and enduring, affecting various aspects of a service member’s personal, professional, and financial life.

6. Can a court-martial conviction be overturned on appeal?

10 Most Commonly Asked Questions About Court Martials military defense attorneysYes, a court-martial conviction can be overturned on appeal. The military justice system provides several levels of appellate review to ensure fairness and accuracy in the administration of justice.

The first level of appeal for a court-martial conviction is the service-specific Court of Criminal Appeals (CCA). Each armed forces branch has its own CCA, such as the Army Court of Criminal Appeals or the Navy-Marine Corps Court of Criminal Appeals. These courts automatically review cases involving sentences of confinement for a year or more, dishonorable or bad-conduct discharges, or dismissal of officers. The CCA can overturn a conviction if it finds legal errors, issues with the sufficiency of the evidence, or if the sentence is deemed inappropriate.

If the CCA upholds the conviction, the next level of appeal is the United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces (CAAF). This court has discretionary review, meaning it selects which cases to hear based on their legal significance. The CAAF can set aside convictions if it identifies substantial legal errors that affected the trial’s outcome.

Beyond the CAAF, a service member can petition the Supreme Court of the United States. However, the Supreme Court accepts very few military cases, typically those with broader constitutional implications.

Additionally, the military justice system includes a mechanism for clemency and parole. Convening authorities and the Secretary of the service branch can provide relief by reducing sentences or overturning convictions. A service member can also request a new trial based on newly discovered evidence or other grounds that could potentially impact the conviction’s validity.

In summary, multiple avenues exist for appealing a court-martial conviction, offering several opportunities for the conviction to be reviewed and potentially overturned if legal or factual errors are found.

7. Will a court-martial conviction affect my civilian life?

A court-martial conviction can significantly impact your civilian life in several ways:

  1. Criminal Record: A court-martial conviction can result in a criminal record. This record can be disclosed in background checks for employment, housing, and other situations, potentially limiting your opportunities. Felony-level convictions, in particular, can severely restrict job prospects, especially in fields requiring security clearances or professional licenses.
  2. Employment: Many employers conduct background checks as part of the hiring process. A court-martial conviction, especially for serious offenses, can make it challenging to secure employment. Employers may view the conviction as a sign of unreliability or a lack of trustworthiness, even if the offense was minor or occurred under unique circumstances.
  3. Professional Licenses and Certifications: Certain professions, such as law, medicine, and finance, require licenses and certifications. A court-martial conviction can jeopardize your ability to obtain or maintain these credentials. Licensing boards often review the character and criminal history of applicants, and a military conviction may lead to denial or revocation of a license.
  4. Educational Opportunities: Some educational institutions and programs, especially those involving sensitive fields, may be hesitant to admit individuals with a criminal record. Additionally, eligibility for certain scholarships and financial aid programs might be affected.
  5. Social Stigma: Beyond the tangible consequences, a court-martial conviction carries a social stigma. Friends, family, and community members may react negatively, affecting personal relationships and social standing. The stigma can lead to isolation and mental health challenges.
  6. Legal Restrictions: Depending on the nature of the conviction, you may face legal restrictions such as loss of the right to vote, own firearms, or hold public office. These restrictions can vary by state and the severity of the offense.
  7. Sex Offender Registration: Sex offender registration requires individuals convicted of sex crimes to provide personal information to a national registry. This includes their name, address, employment, and vehicle details. Registrants must update this information regularly and notify authorities of any changes. The registry is often public, allowing community members to access information about local offenders. The aim is to enhance public safety by monitoring offenders and deterring recidivism. Registration duration varies based on the severity of the crime and jurisdiction, ranging from a few years to a lifetime. Non-compliance can result in additional criminal charges and penalties.

In summary, a court-martial conviction can have lasting repercussions on your civilian life, affecting your career, education, personal relationships, and legal rights. Understanding these potential impacts and seeking legal counsel is crucial if you face a court-martial.

8. Can I be court-martialed after leaving the military?

Yes, you can be court-martialed after leaving the military under certain circumstances. The Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) retains jurisdiction over former service members for specific offenses committed while they were in service. This authority, however, is not unlimited and is typically applied in cases of serious misconduct.

  1. Involuntary Recall: Former service members, especially those who have not completed their Military Service Obligation (MSO), can be involuntarily recalled to active duty to face court-martial charges. This is more common for reservists and those recently separated from service.
  2. Deserters: Individuals who deserted while on active duty can be apprehended and court-martialed regardless of how long their desertion has passed. Desertion is considered a serious offense, and the military maintains the right to prosecute deserters indefinitely.
  3. Fraudulent Discharge: If it is discovered that a service member obtained their discharge fraudulently, the military can revoke the discharge and subject the individual to court-martial. Examples include providing false information to obtain a discharge or concealing significant offenses.
  4. Post-Service Offenses: In rare cases, the UCMJ can apply to actions taken after discharge if those actions have a direct and substantial connection to the individual’s prior military service. This can include misconduct discovered post-discharge that occurred during the period of service.
  5. Retirees: Military retirees, particularly those receiving retirement pay, remain subject to the UCMJ. They can be recalled to active duty to face court-martial for offenses committed before or after retirement. This principle ensures that retirees maintain a level of accountability for their actions.

In conclusion, while it is uncommon, court-martial after leaving the military is possible under specific conditions. It generally involves serious offenses and situations where the military’s interest in maintaining order and discipline is at stake.

9. How can I prepare for a court-martial?

Preparing for a court-martial is a critical process that requires meticulous attention to detail and strategic planning. Here are key steps to ensure you are well-prepared:

  1. Understand the Charges: Familiarize yourself with the specific charges against you. Review the details and understand the elements the prosecution must prove.
  2. Secure Legal Representation: Obtain a qualified military defense attorney. You are entitled to free representation by a military defense counsel, but you may also hire a civilian attorney with expertise in military law.
  3. Gather Evidence: Collect all relevant evidence that supports your defense. This includes documents, emails, text messages, and other records that corroborate your side of the story.
  4. Identify Witnesses: List potential witnesses who can testify on your behalf. This can include colleagues, superiors, and character witnesses. Ensure they are willing and available to testify.
  5. Prepare Your Testimony: Work with your attorney to prepare your testimony. Practice answering questions honestly and clearly. Understand the possible questions the prosecution may ask and prepare for cross-examination.
  6. Understand Court Procedures: Familiarize yourself with the court-martial process. Understand the roles of the judge, jury, and legal representatives. Knowing the procedures can help reduce anxiety and improve your performance.
  7. Stay Organized: Keep all documents, evidence, and correspondence related to your case organized and readily accessible. This will help you and your attorney quickly reference needed information.
  8. Maintain Professionalism: Conduct yourself with professionalism throughout the process. This includes adhering to military standards of conduct and maintaining a respectful demeanor in court.
  9. Take Care of Yourself: Ensure you are physically and mentally prepared. Eat well, get adequate rest, and seek support from trusted friends, family, or counselors.
  10. Stay Informed: Stay updated on any developments in your case. Regularly communicate with your attorney and proactively understand any changes or new strategies.

By following these steps, you can confidently approach your court-martial and be as prepared as possible for the legal challenges ahead.

10. What should I do if I believe I was wrongfully convicted at a court-martial?

If you believe you have been falsely accused of a military crime, taking immediate and strategic action is crucial to protect your rights and ensure a fair outcome. Here are the steps you should follow:

  1. Stay Calm and Composed: It is natural to feel distressed, but staying calm will help you think clearly and make rational decisions.
  2. Invoke Your Rights: Exercise your right to remain silent. Anything you say can be used against you. Politely decline to answer questions until you have legal representation.
  3. Seek Legal Counsel: Contact a military defense attorney as soon as possible. You have the right to legal representation, and a qualified attorney can provide essential guidance and support.
  4. Preserve Evidence: Collect and safeguard any evidence that may support your innocence. This could include documents, emails, text messages, or witness statements that can corroborate your version of events.
  5. Document Everything: Keep detailed records of all interactions related to the accusation, including conversations with investigators, witnesses, and any steps you take in your defense.
  6. Follow Military Protocols: Adhere strictly to military protocols and orders during this time. Non-compliance can be used against you and may complicate your case.
  7. Communicate Through Your Attorney: Let your attorney handle communications with investigators and prosecutors. They understand the legal nuances and can prevent inadvertent self-incrimination.
  8. Prepare for Defense: Work closely with your attorney to build a strong defense. This includes identifying and interviewing witnesses, gathering exculpatory evidence, and developing a comprehensive strategy.
  9. Utilize Support Services: Seek support from available military resources, such as chaplains or mental health services, to help manage stress and maintain emotional well-being during this challenging time.
  10.  Be Proactive: Stay engaged in your defense and maintain regular contact with your attorney to stay informed about the progress of your case.

By taking these steps, you can effectively defend yourself against false accusations and protect your rights within the military justice system.

Skip to content