UCMJ Article 92 – Failure to Obey Orders and Dereliction of Duty
UCMJ Article 92 criminalizes a service member's failure to obey lawful orders or regulations and dereliction in the performance of assigned duties. Article 92 applies to all personnel subject to the UCMJ, across every branch and duty station, regardless of rank or occupational specialty.
To convict under Article 92 dereliction of duty, the government must prove a duty existed, the accused knew or reasonably should have known of it, and the accused willfully, negligently, or through culpable inefficiency failed to perform it. The charged mental state controls the maximum punishment. Gonzalez & Waddington defends service members facing Article 92 charges from investigation through court-martial.
Under the Manual for Courts-Martial, willful Article 92 dereliction carries a maximum of six months confinement, a bad-conduct discharge, and forfeiture of all pay and allowances; dereliction through neglect carries a maximum of three months confinement. A conviction can also result in reduction to E-1, involuntary administrative separation, and revocation of security clearance. A punitive discharge ends federal retirement eligibility and follows a service member into civilian employment.
How Gonzalez & Waddington Defends Article 92 Dereliction Charges
Defending Article 92 dereliction charges requires examining whether the duty was lawfully imposed, clearly communicated, and within the accused's actual capacity to perform. Michael Waddington, a former Army Senior Defense Counsel, scrutinizes evidence of the accused's knowledge of the duty and challenges whether the conduct fell below the standard of care. Defense strategies include contesting the lawfulness of the underlying order, attacking the charged mental state, and presenting mitigating evidence.
Gonzalez & Waddington defends service members from every branch — Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps, Coast Guard, and Space Force — in military courts throughout the United States and overseas, including Germany, Italy, Japan, and South Korea. The firm handles courts-martial, Article 32 hearings, administrative separation boards, and security clearance matters. Service members under investigation or facing Article 92 charges can call 1-800-921-8607 for a confidential consultation.
Reviewed by Michael Waddington, Founding Partner · Updated November 17, 2026
UCMJ Article 92: Dereliction of Duty
Article 92 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice makes it a criminal offense for a service member to violate or fail to obey lawful orders or regulations, or to willfully or negligently perform duties in a deficient manner. The provision is designed to ensure discipline, accountability, and the reliable execution of assigned responsibilities within the armed forces. The statute applies regardless of rank or occupational specialty.
Criminalized Conduct
Article 92 encompasses three primary categories of misconduct. A service member may be charged for violating or failing to obey a lawful general order or regulation, for disobeying any other lawful order, or for dereliction in the performance of duties. Dereliction occurs when a member either willfully neglects a duty, is culpably inefficient in performing it, or fails to perform it through neglect.
- Failure to follow a general order or regulation
- Failure to obey other specific, lawful orders
- Inadequate performance or nonperformance of assigned duties
Persons Subject to Article 92
All individuals subject to the UCMJ may be charged under Article 92, including active-duty personnel, reservists on active status, and certain other categories defined in Article 2 of the UCMJ. The statute applies uniformly across branches and duty stations. Civilian personnel are not charged under Article 92 but may be subject to other administrative or contractual consequences.
Mental State Requirements
The mental state required depends on the specific clause. Violations of lawful orders typically require proof that the order was known and that the member intentionally failed to comply. Dereliction may be based on willful misconduct, culpable inefficiency, or simple negligence, with the degree of fault affecting potential punishment.
Related Liability: Attempt, Conspiracy, and Accomplice Conduct
Attempt and conspiracy liability generally arise under Articles 80 and 81 of the UCMJ rather than Article 92 itself. These theories can apply when a service member takes substantial steps toward violating an order or forms an agreement to do so with others. Aiding and abetting liability may apply under Article 77 when a member assists or encourages another’s violation or dereliction.
Aggressive Military Defense Lawyers: Gonzalez & Waddington
Watch the military defense lawyers at Gonzalez & Waddington break down how they defend service members worldwide against UCMJ allegations, CID/NCIS/OSI investigations, court-martials, Article 120 cases, administrative separations, and GOMORs. If you’re under investigation or facing charges, this video explains what your rights are and how experienced civilian military counsel can make the difference.
Elements of UCMJ Article 92: Dereliction of Duty
The government must prove each element of dereliction of duty beyond a reasonable doubt. These elements define the specific duty at issue, the accused’s knowledge or means of knowledge of that duty, and the nature of the alleged failure to perform it.
Required Elements
- A certain duty existed and was imposed on the accused by statute, regulation, lawful order, standard operating procedure, or the nature of the accused’s position.
- The accused knew or reasonably should have known of that duty.
- The accused was derelict in the performance of that duty by willfully, through negligence, or through culpable inefficiency failing to perform it or performing it improperly.
The mens rea for dereliction of duty varies by the charged theory. Willful dereliction requires proof that the accused intentionally disregarded the known duty. Negligent dereliction requires showing that the accused’s conduct deviated from the standard of care expected of a reasonably prudent service member. Culpable inefficiency involves a level of carelessness amounting to a culpable disregard of duty.
The actus reus consists of an affirmative failure to perform a required duty or an improper performance of that duty. The government must establish both the existence of the duty and the manner in which the accused’s conduct failed to meet its requirements.
Critical statutory terms include “duty,” which encompasses obligations arising from laws, regulations, orders, or inherent responsibilities of a position, and “dereliction,” which denotes performance that falls below the standard required under the circumstances.
Maximum Punishment and Sentencing Exposure
Punishment depends on when the offense was committed. Offenses committed on or before December 27, 2023 are sentenced under the maximum punishments in the Manual for Courts-Martial. Offenses committed after December 27, 2023 are sentenced by a military judge under the sentencing parameters required by the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2022 and set out in Executive Order 14103, which added Appendices 12B through 12D to the Manual for Courts-Martial.
Maximum Punishment for Offenses Committed On or Before December 27, 2023
For offenses committed on or before December 27, 2023, the maximum punishments are those set in Part IV of the Manual for Courts-Martial and summarized in its Appendix 12:
- Dereliction of duty through neglect or culpable inefficiency: forfeiture of two-thirds pay per month for 3 months, confinement for 3 months, and reduction to E-1.
- Dereliction through neglect or culpable inefficiency resulting in death or grievous bodily harm: bad-conduct discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, confinement for 18 months, and reduction to E-1.
- Willful dereliction of duty: bad-conduct discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, confinement for 6 months, and reduction to E-1.
- Willful dereliction resulting in death or grievous bodily harm: dishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, confinement for 2 years, and reduction to E-1.
For commissioned officers, dismissal takes the place of a dishonorable or bad-conduct discharge, and officers cannot be reduced in grade.
Sentencing Parameters for Offenses Committed After December 27, 2023
For offenses committed after December 27, 2023, a military judge sentences the accused within the confinement range for the offense category assigned in Appendix 12C of the Manual for Courts-Martial (2024 ed.). The ranges are set in Appendix 12B (R.C.M. 1002(a)(2)).
- Dereliction through neglect or culpable inefficiency: Category 1, 0 to 12 months of confinement.
- Willful dereliction: Category 1, 0 to 12 months of confinement.
- Dereliction of duty, willful or negligent, resulting in death or grievous bodily harm: Category 2, 1 to 36 months of confinement.
If the maximum confinement for the offense is lower than the top of its category range, the lower maximum controls. The judge may sentence outside a range only after finding specific facts that warrant it and stating them in writing on the record. The parameters govern confinement. A punitive discharge, forfeitures, and reduction in grade remain available up to the maximum punishment for the offense.








How UCMJ Article 92: Dereliction of Duty Is Commonly Charged
In practice, charging decisions under Article 92 for Dereliction of Duty are shaped by concrete fact patterns, the path an allegation takes through investigative channels, and the priorities of the command reviewing the matter. Commands usually look for clear evidence of a duty, a deviation from that duty, and circumstances showing the service member knew or reasonably should have known what was required.
Common Charging Scenarios
Dereliction charges most commonly arise from routine operational environments rather than unusual or extreme misconduct. Typical scenarios include:
- Failure to perform assigned guard, watch, or security duties, especially when logs, cameras, or witness statements show lapses.
- Neglect of administrative or accountability responsibilities, such as weapons accountability, equipment checks, or safety inspections.
- Improper conduct during training events, field operations, or maintenance tasks where specific duties are established by regulation or standard operating procedures.
- Supervisory failures, including inadequate oversight of subordinates, incomplete enforcement of policies, or failure to report known issues to the chain of command.
- Duties associated with medical, financial, or logistical positions where omissions result in identifiable impact on mission or personnel readiness.
Frequently Co-Charged Articles
Prosecutors often pair Article 92 with other UCMJ provisions when the facts support parallel theories of misconduct, such as:
- Article 107 (False Official Statements) when inaccurate reports or logs accompany the alleged dereliction.
- Article 121 (Larceny) or Article 108 (Damage, Loss, or Destruction of Property) when the dereliction involves mishandling government property.
- Article 112a (Drug Offenses) if drug use is alleged to have contributed to the failure to perform required duties.
- Article 133 or 134 when the underlying conduct also implicates standards of officer behavior or prejudicial impact on good order and discipline.
Investigative Pathways
Most Article 92 cases begin with direct reporting by supervisors, irregularities noted during inspections, or complaints from affected personnel. Commands frequently initiate preliminary inquiries or command-directed investigations to establish the duty in question and document alleged deviations. When the matter suggests potential criminality or broader impact, law-enforcement elements such as CID, NCIS, OSI, or CGIS may assume investigative control, conducting interviews, evidence collection, and corroboration through records or digital data.
Charging Trends and Overlap
Article 92 is often used in conjunction with overlapping statutes, allowing prosecutors to frame misconduct through multiple legal avenues. Charge-stacking occurs when both dereliction and related conduct-based articles capture different aspects of the same event. Alternative charging is also common, with prosecutors alleging both willful and negligent dereliction to accommodate varied evidentiary outcomes. These patterns reflect the broad scope of Article 92 and its role as a flexible tool for addressing failures of duty across the full range of military functions.
Common Defenses and Contested Legal Issues
Prosecutions under UCMJ Article 92 for dereliction of duty often turn on whether the government can prove each statutory element beyond a reasonable doubt. Disputes commonly arise regarding the sufficiency of evidence, the credibility of witnesses, the reliability of investigative processes, and the interpretation of statutory or regulatory duties. Courts frequently focus on how these components interact within the specific factual context of the alleged dereliction.
Element-Based Challenges
Controversy often centers on whether the government has established the existence and scope of a duty, the accused’s awareness of that duty, and the alleged failure or neglect. Determining whether a duty is clearly defined in a regulation, order, or custom of the service can be a contested issue, especially when the directive is ambiguous or applied inconsistently. Evidence must typically show the nature of the obligation and whether the accused’s conduct deviated from it. Challenges may arise when documentation is incomplete, when the applicability of a directive is unclear, or when the government relies heavily on inference rather than explicit proof.
Mens Rea and Intent Issues
Mens rea disputes typically involve whether the alleged dereliction was willful, negligent, or the product of simple error. These distinctions materially affect the government’s burden and the characterization of the conduct. Questions often arise regarding the accused’s actual knowledge of a duty or whether a reasonable service member in similar circumstances would have recognized the obligation. Determining the mental state may require interpretation of training materials, duty qualifications, and contemporaneous communications, leading to litigation over how much awareness or foresight the law requires.
Credibility and Factual Disputes
Cases frequently hinge on competing accounts from supervisors, subordinates, or other witnesses. Credibility questions may arise from inconsistent statements, memory limitations, or potential bias stemming from workplace dynamics or command relationships. Investigative interviews, reports, and prior statements may be examined to assess reliability. Factual disputes can affect every element of the offense, including what the duty required, what the accused knew, and how events unfolded.
Evidentiary and Suppression Issues
Litigation often involves challenges to the admissibility of statements made during command inquiries, rights advisements, or inspections. Issues may also arise concerning searches of electronic devices, access to digital communications, or the chain of custody for documentary materials. Courts may evaluate whether evidence was obtained in compliance with the Fourth and Fifth Amendments and military rules of evidence, and whether probative value outweighs potential prejudice.
Statutory Interpretation Issues
Ambiguities in regulatory language, definitional provisions, or cross-referenced duties can lead to disputes over the meaning and scope of Article 92. Questions may center on how broadly a duty should be construed, whether a directive qualifies as a lawful order, or how negligence standards apply. These interpretive issues can shape the contours of the offense and influence how elements are assessed in individual cases.
Related UCMJ Articles
Insubordinate conduct under Article 91, often charged alongside dereliction-related misconduct
Willful disobedience of a commissioned officer, a closely related offense to failure to obey orders
False official statement allegations that are frequently paired with duty-related violations
Conduct unbecoming an officer, which can accompany dereliction charges in officer cases
Collateral Consequences Beyond Court-Martial Punishment
Collateral consequences are administrative, professional, or legal effects that may arise independently of the sentence imposed by a court-martial. These outcomes stem from military regulations, federal rules, or civilian systems that operate alongside the criminal process and may continue to affect a service member after the court-martial has concluded.
Administrative and Career Consequences
A conviction for dereliction of duty under Article 92 can influence several administrative determinations. Commands may initiate administrative separation based on a loss of confidence or unsatisfactory performance, and the characterization of discharge may be affected by the underlying misconduct. Promotion boards may view the conviction as an adverse indicator, potentially limiting advancement. For service members approaching retirement, the conviction may influence retention decisions or high-year tenure considerations. In addition, reenlistment eligibility may be restricted through reenlistment codes or service-specific quality review processes.
Security Clearance and Professional Impact
Dereliction of duty can raise concerns regarding reliability, judgment, and trustworthiness, which may affect eligibility for security clearances or continued access to classified information. Clearance reviews may consider both the conviction and the circumstances surrounding it. Post-service employment in fields requiring clearance eligibility or sensitive positions may also be affected if adjudicators determine that the misconduct reflects negatively on professional suitability.
Registration and Reporting Requirements
Convictions under Article 92 generally do not trigger sex offender registration or similar reporting requirements unless the underlying conduct independently meets federal or state criteria. Registration obligations, when applicable, are governed by civilian law and may vary by jurisdiction.
Related Civilian Legal Exposure
In some cases, the same conduct leading to a dereliction of duty conviction may also violate federal or state law. This may result in potential exposure to civilian criminal investigation or civil claims, depending on the nature of the conduct and local jurisdictional rules.
Immigration and Citizenship Considerations
For non-citizens, certain convictions may factor into assessments of admissibility, removability, or good moral character for naturalization. While dereliction of duty is not categorically disqualifying, immigration authorities may consider the circumstances of the offense when making determinations.
Why Early Legal Representation Matters
During an investigation for UCMJ Article 92: Dereliction of Duty, decisions made in the initial stages often influence the direction and outcome of the case. Actions taken before charges are preferred—including statements, cooperation choices, and responses to command inquiries—can shape both the evidentiary record and how the case is interpreted by investigators and commanders.
Timing of Evidence Collection
Military investigators typically gather statements, documents, and digital data early in the process. Once collected, this evidence may be difficult to modify or contextualize. Early legal involvement helps ensure that evidence is preserved accurately, that service members understand the implications of providing materials, and that any potential misinterpretations are addressed promptly. Civilian military defense lawyers and military counsel can also help evaluate whether the evidence-gathering process complies with applicable regulations.
Risks of Early Interviews
Command or law-enforcement interviews may occur when a service member has limited information about the allegations or the scope of the inquiry. Without guidance, a member may provide incomplete or inaccurate statements, waive rights unintentionally, or agree to questioning without understanding potential consequences. Early representation helps clarify rights and minimizes the risk of misunderstandings.
Command-Driven Investigations
Administrative inquiries and command-directed investigations can proceed independently from any criminal case. Decisions made during these processes—such as initial statements or cooperation levels—may influence administrative outcomes, performance evaluations, or collateral actions. Early legal guidance helps navigate overlapping administrative and criminal considerations.
Long-Term Impact of Early Decisions
Initial choices, including whether to consent to searches, provide documents, or submit written responses, can have lasting effects throughout the case. These decisions may influence charging decisions, plea negotiations, or administrative measures and can shape the record relied on by commanders or legal authorities later in the process.
Video transcript: Article 92 UCMJ Explained | Failure to Obey an Order & Dereliction of Duty
Transcript of the video “Article 92 UCMJ Explained | Failure to Obey an Order & Dereliction of Duty,” with Michael Waddington of Gonzalez & Waddington.
Read the full transcript of this video
Article 92 of the UCMJ makes it a crime to violate a lawful general order or regulation, to fail to obey any other lawful order you know about, or to be derelict in the performance of your duties. It’s one of the most frequently charged articles in the military because it turns almost any rule, policy, or task into a potential criminal offense. I’m Michael Waddington, civilian military defense lawyer and co-founder of Gonzalez & Waddington. Here’s how Article 92 works, what each version carries, and how these charges are defended.
First, violating a general order or regulation. A general order is issued by the president, the secretary of defense, a service secretary, or a general or flag officer in command, or a commander with general court-martial authority. To be enforceable under Article 92, it has to be punitive, meaning it says that violations can be punished under the UCMJ. Many regulations aren’t punitive.
Others have specific punitive paragraphs. For a general order, the government doesn’t have to prove you knew about it. You’re presumed to know. Common examples include fraternization and relationship rules, hazing and bullying policies, the Department of Defense ban on hemp, CBD, and Delta 8 products, extremism and political activity rules, overseas liberty and curfew orders, and alcohol restrictions.
Second, failing to obey other lawful orders. These are orders that aren’t general orders. An order from your squad leader, a commander’s no contact order, a restriction to the installation, a command policy letter, or an order to report somewhere. For these, the government has to prove that the order was lawful, that you had a duty to obey it, that you actually knew about it, and that you failed to obey.
Knowledge is a real element here. And I was never told is a real defense when it’s true. Third, dereliction of duty. You’re derelict when you had certain duties, knew or reasonably should have known about them, and failed to perform them either willfully or through neglect or culpable inefficiency.
Duties can come from regulations, orders, standard operating procedures, or the customs of the service. Examples: failing to conduct required checks on watch, negligent handling of classified material, failing to supervise subordinates, failing to report an incident, or not completing a required inspection. But dereliction requires more than a mistake. Ineptitude, meaning you tried and simply weren’t able to do it well, is not dereliction.
Fourth, the punishment. Violating a general order or regulation carries up to 2 years and a dishonorable discharge. Failing to obey another lawful order carries up to six months and a bad conduct discharge. Willful dereliction carries up to six months and a bad conduct discharge.
And negligent dereliction up to 3 months. If dereliction results in death or grievous bodily harm, the maximums rise to 18 months for negligence and 2 years for willful dereliction. Most Article 92 cases go to non-judicial punishment, but they’re also routinely added to court-martial charge sheets. Fifth, why Article 92 is everywhere?
Because it’s flexible. A sexual harassment allegation can be charged as a violation of a harassment regulation. A relationship can be charged as violating a fraternization policy. A hemp product becomes a general order violation.
A lost weapon becomes dereliction. Prosecutors use Article 92 as a backup when they’re not sure they can prove a more specific offense and as an add-on to increase leverage. Defending it starts with reading the actual order or regulation line by line. Sixth, the defenses.
The order wasn’t lawful. An order has to relate to a military duty, can’t be for purely private purposes, and can’t violate the Constitution or another law. The regulation isn’t punitive. If it doesn’t say violations are punishable under the UCMJ, it can’t support a general order charge.
No knowledge. For orders other than general orders, you have to have actually known about the order. Ambiguity. An order that’s unclear, contradictory, or superseded is hard to enforce.
Impossibility. You couldn’t comply through no fault of your own. No duty or no knowledge of the duty for dereliction. And ineptitude rather than neglect, which isn’t criminal.
Seventh, the administrative side. Article 92 violations often show up as the basis for reprimands, adverse evaluations, relief for cause, and administrative separation. Even when the evidence of a crime is thin, commands use the findings of a command investigation to take administrative action. That’s why the investigation stage matters and why your written responses to reprimands and evaluations need to address the regulation itself, not just the facts.
Eighth, what to do. One, get a copy of the exact order or regulation you’re accused of violating, including the version in effect at the time. Two, don’t make statements to your command or an investigating officer without a lawyer. Three, gather evidence of what you were told, when, and by whom, including emails, briefings, sign-in sheets, and acknowledgement forms.
Four, identify witnesses who can speak to how the order was communicated and how it was enforced on others. Five, talk to a lawyer before accepting an Article 15, especially if the charge could support a separation. At Gonzalez & Waddington, we’ve beaten Article 92 charges by showing the regulation wasn’t punitive, the order wasn’t lawful, or the duty was never clearly established. So, what is Article 92 of the UCMJ?
It covers violating a general order, failing to obey another lawful order, and dereliction of duty with punishments from three months up to two years, and a dishonorable discharge. I’m Michael Waddington, a civilian military defense lawyer and co-founder of Gonzalez & Waddington with my law partner, Alexandra González-Waddington. For more than 20 years, we’ve defended service members stationed around the world in military investigations, courts-martial, Article 15s, reprimands, and administrative separation boards. If you’re facing a failure to obey or dereliction of duty charge, don’t wait.
The decisions you make early can shape the entire case. When the government builds a case, we build your defense. You can learn more at ucmjdefense.com or call 1-800-921-8607 for a free confidential consultation. When the command knows you’ve got real defense, the game changes.
About Gonzalez & Waddington
Gonzalez & Waddington is a civilian military defense law firm that focuses on representing service members facing UCMJ investigations, administrative actions, and courts-martial. The firm handles cases across all branches of the armed forces and is experienced in the complexities of military justice, including matters arising under Article 92: Dereliction of Duty.
How We Help in UCMJ Article 92: Dereliction of Duty
- Court-martial defense: Representation in Article 92 trials, including case preparation, evidence review, and defense strategy.
- Military criminal investigations: Guidance and advocacy during CID, NCIS, OSI, and CGIS investigations related to alleged dereliction of duty.
- Command-directed investigations: Support during inquiries such as command investigations and AR 15-6 proceedings, including responses to allegations of failure to perform duties.
- Administrative separation boards: Representation in boards and adverse administrative actions initiated because of alleged violations of Article 92.
- Rights advisement: Counsel on navigating interviews, statements, and interactions with command during a pending Article 92 allegation.
If you are facing an investigation or adverse action involving Article 92: Dereliction of Duty, Gonzalez & Waddington can provide guidance on your options and help you understand the process. To discuss your situation in confidence, you may contact the firm to request a consultation.
Video transcript
Transcript of the video “Called to CID, NCIS, OSI, or CGIS? What to Expect,” with Michael Waddington of Gonzalez & Waddington.
Read the full transcript of this video
My name is Michael Waddington, and I’m a criminal defense attorney. I want to talk to you briefly about what you can expect if you get brought into CID, NCIS, OSI, or CGIS.
First of all, they might not give you a heads-up. You might have someone from your command drive you there, thinking you’re going to turn in some equipment or run to the PX, and next thing you know, you’re dropped off at law enforcement. The first thing you should do is make sure your phone is off, and don’t bring it in there, because once you bring it in, they’ll take it, and you’re probably never getting it back. Even if the case is unsubstantiated, it is a fight to get phones back from law enforcement once they seize them. Obviously, if they have a search warrant, they can take it. But what you don’t want to be doing is volunteering your phone to them. What they’re going to end up doing is digging through your phone, maybe with your consent, looking for anything they can use against you.
Once you get inside, they’re probably going to tell you to have a seat. There are usually some crappy chairs in there with some outdated magazines or some hunting magazines, and they’ll often leave you there with the camera on you for hours. They do that on purpose. They’re probably watching behind the camera, because there’s a camera in almost every one of these offices. They can see who’s there, and they’re back there eating Twinkies and joking around, just trying to build up your anxiety.
So what you can do when you get there is immediately tell them that you want an attorney. You’re being ordered to come here; you know that they may be taking your fingerprints, DNA, and photograph, which they can do. Tell them that you’re not speaking to them, that you want an attorney, and ask them, “Am I free to leave?” When they know that you mean business and you’re not going to make a statement or consent, you’ve just made their day easier, and they want to get rid of you. But when they think you’re going to try to talk to them or explain yourself, or that you’re easy prey, they will let you sit there.
A lot of times, once they bring you back into their offices, they’ll put you in a room. It’s an interrogation room. It usually has a two-way mirror with a video camera, and it has some crappy chair in the corner, and they’re going to put you in the corner. They do that if they think you’re going to talk. If you tell them again, “I want a lawyer,” or “I have a lawyer” (that’s the best scenario: “I have a lawyer, here’s their information, please call them right now”), that’s usually the end of it. They’re going to be like, “Okay, let me just get your fingerprints, DNA, and photograph, and we’ll get you out of here.”
But when they don’t think you have a lawyer, they’re going to move into what’s called rapport building. Rapport building is where they just BS with you: “Oh, hey, I hear you’re from Pittsburgh. How about the Steelers this weekend? What about that interception? Hey, I heard you deployed. What unit were you with?” And by the way, when they think you’re going to talk, they put someone in there who can identify with you. So if you’re an African-American person from St. Louis, they might put someone in there who’s from your racial background, or religion, or demographic area, to try to build rapport. By rapport, I mean build up some friendship, some bond, like “we’re buddies.” They usually do that for anywhere from 20 to 30 minutes, but they’re following a script. Their script tells them to do these things. Their training tells them to do these things.
By the time they’re done with rapport building, they think they have you on the ropes: “We’re going to get this guy to make a bunch of statements, and we’re going to use them against him.” And then they say, “Ah, I’ve got a little legal technicality here,” and they’ll whip out a legal technicality, which is your constitutional right to an attorney, and they’ll make it sound like it’s nothing: “Just sign right here.” That’s when you realize what you’re being accused of. Now, even if you tell them in the beginning, “Hey, I want a lawyer,” they’re going to have you sign that document invoking on paper, so they have it documented. So you’ll usually get to see what’s on the paper anyway.
A lot of times, people see what’s on the paper and think, “What the hell? Kidnapping and child rape? I thought I was brought down here for underage drinking.” And they’re filming this whole thing. They do that for the shock. Then they say, “Listen, you’re not accused. We just got some information. We need to clarify a few things,” and they start trying to BS with you, and a lot of people want to start talking.
These are professionals, and they have someone outside the room, usually someone very seasoned (a warrant officer in many of the branches), telling them what to do. What they’re doing is, little by little, getting you to admit to things. It could be very simple things: “Hey, do you know this person?” “Yeah.” “When’s the last time you saw them?” They’re looking to see if you admit to certain elements, or if they think you’re lying about certain elements, because in their mind they have it made up: you’re guilty. This person said something happened. They believe the victims. They’ll all tell you that nowadays; they’ll just admit it: “We start by believing the victims. We don’t investigate the victims,” and so forth.
So they will continue to interrogate you and escalate it. If you say, “Hey, I didn’t do that,” that’s a denial. They have a manual that tells them how to deal with denials. The way they deal with denials is by framing the next question so it has two incriminating answers: “We think it’s one of two ways. You either had sex with someone who maybe had a little bit too much to drink, and you maybe thought she wanted it, or you’re a goddamn rapist. Which is it?” Now notice, both of those point to guilt. Either you had sex with someone who was too drunk to consent, or you just straight-up raped the person.
So they’ll keep going and going. Until you tell them, “I want a lawyer. Am I free to leave? I want a lawyer. Am I free to leave?” you’re going to be stuck there, going round and round, sometimes six, seven, eight, nine, ten hours. They’ll bring you food, coffee, and snacks on camera: “Oh, you want Burger King? Here you go. What’s your favorite, a Coke?” They do that so that on cross-examination at your trial, they can say, “Hey, I offered this guy a Coke, and I even bought him a Double Whopper, and he ate it all, and we sat there together. So there’s no coercion.” That’s the reason they do that. Once you ask them repeatedly, “Am I free to leave? I want an attorney,” you will be allowed to leave, and you’ll go back to your unit. Unless and until you do that, they will keep you there.
So the bottom line is, it’s advisable to seek out an attorney immediately if you’re brought to any of these law enforcement investigation offices, questioned, or read your rights. That is the best way to make sure you know what you’re dealing with. You’re not going to know how to deal with professional law enforcement agents and their team of prosecutors on your own. If you have any questions, you can always reach out to my firm, or any other lawyer who is competent to represent you in a military criminal case.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What does UCMJ Article 92: Dereliction of Duty cover?
A: Article 92 addresses a service member’s failure to perform assigned duties or performing them in a negligent or willful manner. It also covers violations of lawful general orders or regulations and failure to obey other lawful orders. The article applies when a duty is established, the member knew or should have known about the duty, and they failed to meet the required standard of performance. It applies across all branches of the armed forces.
Q: What is the maximum punishment for UCMJ Article 92: Dereliction of Duty?
A: The maximum punishment depends on the specific nature of the violation. A willful dereliction can lead to harsher penalties than a negligent dereliction. Potential punishments may include confinement, reduction in grade, forfeiture of pay, or a punitive discharge if addressed at a court-martial. The exact exposure varies based on the circumstances, the member’s record, and whether the case is charged alongside additional misconduct.
Q: Can an allegation under this article lead to administrative separation even without a conviction?
A: Yes. Commands may initiate administrative separation based on substantiated misconduct or a pattern of performance concerns, even without a court-martial conviction. Administrative processes operate under different evidentiary and procedural standards than criminal proceedings. As a result, a service member may face career-impacting actions, including separation or characterization of service decisions, based on the command’s assessment of the underlying conduct and its effects on mission readiness or discipline.
Q: Do I need a civilian military defense lawyer for an investigation under this article?
A: A service member is not required to hire a civilian defense lawyer, but may choose to do so. Military defense counsel are available at no cost, and civilian counsel can provide additional representation if desired. The decision often depends on the seriousness of the allegations, the potential consequences, and the service member’s preference for personalized legal support. Both military and civilian counsel can advise on rights, procedures, and likely command actions.
Q: Can an allegation of dereliction of duty be handled without a court-martial?
A: Yes. Commands may address alleged dereliction through administrative measures or nonjudicial punishment instead of a court-martial. Options may include counseling, reprimands, corrective training, Article 15 or NJP proceedings, or other command-directed actions. These alternatives allow the command to respond to the conduct while using a process that requires fewer procedural steps. The chosen approach generally depends on the severity of the conduct and any related mission or discipline concerns.
Q: Which agencies typically investigate alleged dereliction of duty?
A: The investigating agency varies by the circumstances and the service branch. Many cases are handled at the unit level through command-directed inquiries. More serious or complex allegations may involve organizations such as CID, NCIS, or OSI when criminal violations are suspected. The scope of the investigation is determined by the potential impact on mission performance, involvement of other offenses, and the need for formal fact-finding and documentation.
Q: What types of evidence are commonly used to evaluate a dereliction of duty allegation?
A: Evidence may include duty rosters, written or verbal orders, operational logs, witness statements, training records, and performance reports. Commands may also review emails, messages, or other documentation showing what the service member knew and when. The focus is on establishing the existence of a duty, the service member’s awareness of that duty, and whether their performance met the required standard. Both direct and circumstantial evidence may be considered.
You can review the individual Articles of the UCMJ and learn more about military law by clicking here: UCMJ Articles and Military Justice Resources. You can also explore official military law guidance from the Army Judge Advocate General’s Corps at jagcnet.army.mil.

Michael Waddington
A former Army JAG, best-selling author and FIU adjunct law professor, Michael Waddington defends clients worldwide in serious cases and trains lawyers in advanced cross-examination. He is frequently featured by major media outlets like CNN and 60 Minutes.

Alexandra González-Waddington
Alexandra González-Waddington is a military and civilian defense attorney with more than 20 years of experience who has handled high-profile sexual assault, violent crime, and war-crimes cases globally. Her work is widely recognized by media outlets including 60 Minutes and ABC’s Nightline.