UCMJ Military Defense Guide by Gonzalez & Waddington
Article 92 of the UCMJ is one of the most frequently charged offenses in the United States military. It covers a wide range of misconduct, from violating written regulations to disobeying lawful orders to failing to perform duties. Because it is so broad, Article 92 is often used as a “catch-all” charge when commands want to take action but have weak evidence of more serious misconduct.
Service members across the country — especially in high-tempo states like Florida — face Article 92 charges for reasons ranging from alcohol incidents, fraternization allegations, safety violations, administrative errors, and command climate complaints. Florida installations such as NAS Jacksonville, Mayport, Pensacola, Whiting Field, Eglin, Hurlburt, Tyndall, MacDill, and Patrick Space Force Base frequently issue Article 92 charges due to their intense operational climates and strict leadership expectations.
Gonzalez & Waddington, Attorneys at Law defends service members worldwide who are accused of violating Article 92. Our firm combines decades of courtroom experience, deep UCMJ knowledge, and national-level authority to protect military careers against unfair, exaggerated, or retaliatory Article 92 allegations.
➤ Speak With a Military Defense Lawyer About Your Article 92 Case
What Is Article 92 UCMJ?
Article 92 covers three distinct types of violations:
- 92(1) – Violating or failing to obey a lawful general order or regulation
- 92(2) – Failing to obey a lawful order
- 92(3) – Dereliction of duty
Although grouped under the same Article, these are legally different offenses, each with unique elements and defenses. Understanding which version the government is accusing you of is the first step to building a strong defense.
Elements of Article 92
Violation of a General Order or Regulation – Article 92(1)
- A general order or regulation existed
- The accused had a duty to obey the order/regulation
- The accused violated or failed to obey it
Failure to Obey a Lawful Order – Article 92(2)
- A specific lawful order was issued
- The accused knew of the order
- The accused failed to obey or disobeyed the order
Dereliction of Duty – Article 92(3)
- The accused had a certain duty
- The accused knew or reasonably should have known of the duty
- The accused was derelict (negligent, willful, or culpably inefficient)
Maximum Punishments Under Article 92
The maximum punishment depends on the subsection. The harshest penalties apply to violating a general order or regulation.
- Dishonorable discharge
- Confinement up to 2 years
- Reduction to E-1
- Total forfeitures
Dereliction of duty typically carries lighter punishments, but a conviction can still destroy your career, especially in high-visibility regions like Florida.
Common Article 92 Scenarios
1. Liberty Violations
- Breaking liberty hour restrictions
- Drinking restrictions in training commands (Pensacola, Whiting)
- Returning late to ship or command
2. Alcohol Misconduct
- Drinking while on duty
- Consuming alcohol while under age
- Violating command alcohol policies
3. Relationship Violations
- Fraternization orders
- No-contact orders
- Orders restricting communication during investigations
4. Domestic Violence-Related Orders
- Military protective orders (MPOs)
- No-contact with spouse/partner
- Home restrictions issued after a domestic call
5. Administrative/Professional Failures
- Safety violations
- Failure to maintain readiness
- Improper reporting or documentation
6. Training Command Scenarios
- “Phase liberty” violations
- Breaking uniform or grooming requirements
- Improper barracks procedures
7. COVID-Era & Emergency Orders
- Mask orders
- Quarantine or restriction-of-movement violations
- Command-directed testing orders
How the Military Investigates Article 92
Article 92 cases may involve:
- NCIS – Navy/Marine Corps
- OSI – Air Force/Space Force
- CID – Army
- CGIS – Coast Guard
- Command Investigations (15-6, JAGMAN, CDI)
Common Investigator Tactics
- Presenting the order without explaining context
- Claiming “you signed a page 13” when you didn’t
- Misstating what the order required
- Collecting statements from biased or intoxicated witnesses
- Failing to review digital evidence or text messages
In Florida, investigators often escalate minor infractions due to high operational tempo, media pressure, and command sensitivity.
How Gonzalez & Waddington Defends Article 92 Charges
Our firm uses a multi-layered defense strategy that dismantles Article 92 cases from every angle:
1. Proving the Order was NOT Lawful
- Order must come from proper authority
- Must relate to military duty
- Must not violate constitutional rights
2. Proving the Service Member Never Received the Order
- No signature documenting receipt
- No briefing documentation
- Order not clearly communicated
3. Proving the Accused Did Not KNOW About the Order
- Ambiguous instructions
- Poorly distributed guidance
- Incorrect version circulated
4. Challenging Dereliction Allegations
- Undefined or unreasonable duties
- Overlapping responsibilities
- Improper expectations or training gaps
5. Command Climate & Retaliation Defense
- Disputes between supervisors
- Likes/dislikes influencing allegations
- Retaliation after reporting misconduct
6. Florida-Specific Defense Strategies
- Orders issued due to nightlife or alcohol culture
- Barracks conflicts mistakenly escalated
- Training command overreach
- Ship or squadron commands reacting to PR pressure
Pro Tips for Service Members Charged with Article 92
- Do NOT admit you knew the order existed unless proven.
- Save all texts, emails, logs, rosters, and message traffic.
- Document how the order was communicated (or wasn’t).
- Write a timeline immediately.
- Do NOT try to “explain” to investigators.
- Avoid discussing the case with coworkers.
- Request the written order through legal channels.
- Get legal counsel before NJP, Mast, or Article 15.
- Do NOT waive your rights under pressure.
Related UCMJ Articles
- UCMJ Article Hub
- Article 90 – Willful Disobedience of Superior Officer
- Article 91 – Insubordination Toward NCO
- Article 86 – AWOL
- Article 95 – Resistance, Flight, Escape
Article 92 UCMJ – Frequently Asked Questions
Can I be convicted of Article 92 if I never saw the order?
Not necessarily. The government must prove you knew or reasonably should have known about the order. Gonzalez & Waddington frequently wins cases by showing the order was unclear, improperly distributed, or not lawfully given.
Is violating a general order more serious than disobeying a direct order?
Yes. Violating a general order (92(1)) carries harsher penalties and often results in court-martial. Commands in Florida enforce general orders aggressively, especially in aviation, SOF, and training units.
What is dereliction of duty?
Dereliction means failing to perform assigned duties willfully, negligently, or through inefficiency. Many dereliction cases involve unclear duties, inadequate training, or unreasonable expectations — all strong defenses.
Can Article 92 charges be reduced?
Absolutely. Many Article 92 cases collapse under scrutiny. Gonzalez & Waddington frequently gets charges dropped, reduced to minor offenses, or dismissed entirely through aggressive pre-trial strategy.
Why choose Gonzalez & Waddington for Article 92 defense?
Our firm has decades of military trial experience, focused cross-examination skills, and experience dismantling weak Article 92 cases. We defend service members at every Florida installation and worldwide.
How do I get legal help now?
Visit
https://ucmjdefense.com/florida-military-defense-lawyers/
to request a confidential case review. Our team responds quickly and develops an immediate strategy to protect your career.
Video transcript: Article 92 UCMJ Explained | Failure to Obey an Order & Dereliction of Duty
Transcript of the video “Article 92 UCMJ Explained | Failure to Obey an Order & Dereliction of Duty,” with Michael Waddington of Gonzalez & Waddington.
Read the full transcript of this video
Article 92 of the UCMJ makes it a crime to violate a lawful general order or regulation, to fail to obey any other lawful order you know about, or to be derelict in the performance of your duties. It’s one of the most frequently charged articles in the military because it turns almost any rule, policy, or task into a potential criminal offense. I’m Michael Waddington, civilian military defense lawyer and co-founder of Gonzalez & Waddington. Here’s how Article 92 works, what each version carries, and how these charges are defended.
First, violating a general order or regulation. A general order is issued by the president, the secretary of defense, a service secretary, or a general or flag officer in command, or a commander with general court-martial authority. To be enforceable under Article 92, it has to be punitive, meaning it says that violations can be punished under the UCMJ. Many regulations aren’t punitive.
Others have specific punitive paragraphs. For a general order, the government doesn’t have to prove you knew about it. You’re presumed to know. Common examples include fraternization and relationship rules, hazing and bullying policies, the Department of Defense ban on hemp, CBD, and Delta 8 products, extremism and political activity rules, overseas liberty and curfew orders, and alcohol restrictions.
Second, failing to obey other lawful orders. These are orders that aren’t general orders. An order from your squad leader, a commander’s no contact order, a restriction to the installation, a command policy letter, or an order to report somewhere. For these, the government has to prove that the order was lawful, that you had a duty to obey it, that you actually knew about it, and that you failed to obey.
Knowledge is a real element here. And I was never told is a real defense when it’s true. Third, dereliction of duty. You’re derelict when you had certain duties, knew or reasonably should have known about them, and failed to perform them either willfully or through neglect or culpable inefficiency.
Duties can come from regulations, orders, standard operating procedures, or the customs of the service. Examples: failing to conduct required checks on watch, negligent handling of classified material, failing to supervise subordinates, failing to report an incident, or not completing a required inspection. But dereliction requires more than a mistake. Ineptitude, meaning you tried and simply weren’t able to do it well, is not dereliction.
Fourth, the punishment. Violating a general order or regulation carries up to 2 years and a dishonorable discharge. Failing to obey another lawful order carries up to six months and a bad conduct discharge. Willful dereliction carries up to six months and a bad conduct discharge.
And negligent dereliction up to 3 months. If dereliction results in death or grievous bodily harm, the maximums rise to 18 months for negligence and 2 years for willful dereliction. Most Article 92 cases go to non-judicial punishment, but they’re also routinely added to court-martial charge sheets. Fifth, why Article 92 is everywhere?
Because it’s flexible. A sexual harassment allegation can be charged as a violation of a harassment regulation. A relationship can be charged as violating a fraternization policy. A hemp product becomes a general order violation.
A lost weapon becomes dereliction. Prosecutors use Article 92 as a backup when they’re not sure they can prove a more specific offense and as an add-on to increase leverage. Defending it starts with reading the actual order or regulation line by line. Sixth, the defenses.
The order wasn’t lawful. An order has to relate to a military duty, can’t be for purely private purposes, and can’t violate the Constitution or another law. The regulation isn’t punitive. If it doesn’t say violations are punishable under the UCMJ, it can’t support a general order charge.
No knowledge. For orders other than general orders, you have to have actually known about the order. Ambiguity. An order that’s unclear, contradictory, or superseded is hard to enforce.
Impossibility. You couldn’t comply through no fault of your own. No duty or no knowledge of the duty for dereliction. And ineptitude rather than neglect, which isn’t criminal.
Seventh, the administrative side. Article 92 violations often show up as the basis for reprimands, adverse evaluations, relief for cause, and administrative separation. Even when the evidence of a crime is thin, commands use the findings of a command investigation to take administrative action. That’s why the investigation stage matters and why your written responses to reprimands and evaluations need to address the regulation itself, not just the facts.
Eighth, what to do. One, get a copy of the exact order or regulation you’re accused of violating, including the version in effect at the time. Two, don’t make statements to your command or an investigating officer without a lawyer. Three, gather evidence of what you were told, when, and by whom, including emails, briefings, sign-in sheets, and acknowledgement forms.
Four, identify witnesses who can speak to how the order was communicated and how it was enforced on others. Five, talk to a lawyer before accepting an Article 15, especially if the charge could support a separation. At Gonzalez & Waddington, we’ve beaten Article 92 charges by showing the regulation wasn’t punitive, the order wasn’t lawful, or the duty was never clearly established. So, what is Article 92 of the UCMJ?
It covers violating a general order, failing to obey another lawful order, and dereliction of duty with punishments from three months up to two years, and a dishonorable discharge. I’m Michael Waddington, a civilian military defense lawyer and co-founder of Gonzalez & Waddington with my law partner, Alexandra González-Waddington. For more than 20 years, we’ve defended service members stationed around the world in military investigations, courts-martial, Article 15s, reprimands, and administrative separation boards. If you’re facing a failure to obey or dereliction of duty charge, don’t wait.
The decisions you make early can shape the entire case. When the government builds a case, we build your defense. Visit ucmjdefense.com or call 1-800-921-8607 for a free confidential consultation. When the command knows you’ve got real defense, the game changes.
ot real defense, the game changes.