Mastering Cross-Examination: Using True or False Questions to Control Difficult Witnesses
Cross-examination is often the most challenging part of any trial. For attorneys, especially those new to courtroom litigation, managing difficult witnesses can feel like an uphill battle. How do you maintain control and keep a witness on track when they’re evasive or hostile? One powerful technique, highlighted by trial attorney and bestselling author Michael Waddington, is the strategic use of True or False questions. In this article, we’ll explore how this method works, why it’s effective, and how you can incorporate it into your litigation toolkit to gain an edge in the courtroom.
Why Controlling Difficult Witnesses Matters
Witnesses who are uncooperative or evasive can derail the flow of your case, confuse the jury, and weaken your position. The ability to maintain control during cross-examination is critical for presenting a compelling narrative and exposing inconsistencies or weaknesses in the opposing party’s story. Michael Waddington, a seasoned trial lawyer with an international practice and author of The Art of Trial Warfare, has developed and taught numerous techniques designed specifically to keep witnesses in check.
Technique #4: True or False Questions Explained
True or False questions are deceptively simple but highly effective. As Waddington explains, these questions leverage the binary nature of true or false answers to limit a witness’s ability to evade or expand beyond yes/no responses. The technique is inspired by the true or false tests many of us took as children, but adapted for the courtroom’s high-stakes environment.
For example, in a custody case scenario, a lawyer might ask:
“You recommended that the guardian receive full custody of the child. True or false?”
When the witness responds affirmatively, the lawyer can follow up with a clarifying statement that forces a straightforward answer, such as:
“You never performed a drug test on the guardian. True or false?”
The witness may try to provide a non-responsive answer or qualify the response, but by pausing and repeating the true or false framing, the lawyer pins down the witness, preventing evasiveness.
Why This Technique Works
- Limits Witness Evasion: True or false questions restrict a witness’s answers to a simple binary choice, reducing the opportunity for long-winded or evasive answers.
- Maintains Control: By forcing yes/no style answers, the attorney controls the pace and direction of the examination.
- Clarifies Testimony: The technique helps to crystallize important facts, making it easier for judges and juries to understand key points.
- Psychological Pressure: The straightforward nature of the question puts witnesses on the spot, often compelling them to respond honestly or risk appearing deceptive.
Integrating True or False Questions into Your Cross-Examination Strategy
While true or false questions are a powerful tool, their effectiveness increases when used alongside other cross-examination techniques. Michael Waddington’s nine techniques for controlling difficult witnesses include:
- Repeat the question.
- Repeat twice and then reverse.
- Confirm answers with “So, your answer to my question is ‘Yes/No’?”
- True or false.
- Clarify misunderstandings with “Perhaps I did not make myself clear.”
- Confirm hearing with “Did you hear the question I asked?”
- Address witness’s urge to explain with “There are lots of things you want to tell the jury?”
- Identify obstacles with “Does something prevent you from answering yes or no?”
- Manage time with “Are you finished yet?”
Employing multiple techniques in combination can keep a witness on the defensive and ensure your questions are answered precisely.
Additional Insights From Michael Waddington’s Expertise
Michael Waddington is not just a practicing trial attorney but also a renowned educator and author. His bestselling books like The Art of Trial Warfare and Kick-Ass Closings are widely used by trial lawyers and law schools nationwide. Waddington emphasizes the importance of preparation, clear questioning, and strategic control over courtroom dynamics to win cases.
His body of work includes pattern cross-examinations for various fact patterns, including sexual assault and expert witness testimony, providing invaluable resources for criminal and civil defense lawyers. The true or false technique fits squarely into his philosophy of precision and control in trial advocacy.
Conclusion: Elevate Your Cross-Examination Skills
Mastering cross-examination is essential for trial lawyers seeking to effectively dismantle opposing testimony and present a compelling case. The true or false question technique offers a straightforward yet potent way to control difficult witnesses and extract clear, concise answers. By integrating this approach into your broader cross-examination strategies, you can enhance your courtroom effectiveness and improve your chances of success.
For more insights and practical examples, consider exploring Michael Waddington’s teaching materials and books, which remain go-to resources for legal professionals nationwide.
Ready to sharpen your trial skills? Start incorporating true or false questions in your next cross-examination and experience the difference!
Watch the original video and subscribe for more trial tips: Cross-Examination Questions: Technique #4 Control Difficult Witnesses