Mastering Cross-Examination: How to Control Difficult Witnesses Like a Pro

Cross-examination is one of the most critical phases in any trial, often making or breaking a case. However, when faced with difficult witnesses, even the most prepared attorneys can find themselves challenged. How do you maintain control, keep the witness accountable, and ensure clear, concise answers? In this post, we dive deep into Kick-Ass Cross Exam Technique #8, expertly taught by seasoned trial attorney Michael Waddington, to help you master the art of controlling difficult witnesses on cross-examination.

Introduction: The Importance of Controlling Difficult Witnesses

Picture this: You’re in the courtroom, and the witness is dodging your questions, giving vague or evasive answers, or piling on confusing details. This not only wastes valuable time but can also weaken your case and frustrate the judge and jury. As Michael Waddington highlights, controlling these witnesses is essential to maintain the narrative, expose inconsistencies, and ultimately advocate effectively for your client.

In this blog post, we analyze the key technique presented in the video, including practical examples, and provide additional insights to help both novice and experienced attorneys sharpen their cross-examination skills.

Technique #8: Asking “Does Something Prevent You From Answering Yes or No?” – Why It Works

One of the fundamental challenges in cross-examination is eliciting clean yes-or-no answers. Difficult witnesses often respond with long explanations, compound answers, or outright refusals to provide simple clarity. Michael Waddington’s technique involves directly confronting this obstacle by asking, “Does something prevent you from answering yes or no?”

This question serves multiple strategic purposes:

• Clarifies the witness’s hesitation: It forces the witness to articulate if there’s a legitimate reason for avoiding a simple answer.
• Prevents evasive or compound answers: Complex or multi-part questions can confuse witnesses or allow them to dodge. This technique calls out that behavior.
• Maintains control of the narrative: By insisting on a yes or no, the attorney keeps the examination focused and concise, making it easier for the judge or jury to follow.
• Exposes weaknesses or contradictions: When witnesses cannot justify their avoidance, it may reveal uncertainty or dishonesty.

Example Breakdown

Michael Waddington provides a telling example in the video:

“Amber, you testified that you donated $7 million to the Children’s Burn Hospital.”
“Yes.”
“As of June 2022, none of the $7 million has been transferred to the hospital. You obviously don’t understand how charitable donations work. When you make a donation, the hospital has pledged that amount and they receive the money as part of the donation. Amber, is there something about my question that prevents you from answering yes or no?”

Here, the attorney challenges the witness with a direct fact, then calls out any confusion or refusal to answer by inviting the witness to explain their inability to respond straightforwardly. This approach helps prevent the witness from hiding behind ambiguity or complicated explanations.

Additional Context: Why Controlling Difficult Witnesses Matters

In legal proceedings, the ability to control the flow of information is essential. Witnesses who ramble, refuse to answer, or provide evasive responses can derail the examination and weaken the attorney’s position. Beyond just eliciting facts, controlling witnesses helps to:

• Build credibility: A lawyer who maintains control appears more confident and authoritative, which can positively influence the judge and jury.
• Reduce confusion: Clear yes/no answers reduce ambiguity and make it easier to highlight contradictions or inconsistencies in testimony.
• Manage courtroom dynamics: Difficult witnesses can frustrate proceedings; controlling them keeps the trial on track and professional.

Michael Waddington, along with Alexandra Waddington, is known for aggressive and effective criminal defense strategies, especially in complex military and state court cases. Their approach to cross-examination is rooted in years of experience defending serious charges, including sex crimes, false accusations, and military sexual assault cases, demonstrating the effectiveness of these practical techniques in high-stakes environments.

Practical Tips for Implementing This Technique

If you want to apply Kick-Ass Cross Exam Technique #8 in your next trial or mock session, consider the following tips:

1. Prepare your questions carefully: Ensure they are simple, focused, and designed to elicit yes or no answers without ambiguity.
2. Watch for evasive behavior: Be alert when a witness dodges or complicates answers. That’s your cue to ask if something prevents a yes or no response.
3. Stay calm and assertive: This question is a gentle but firm way to regain control without appearing confrontational.
4. Use it sparingly but effectively: Overuse may irritate the court or the witness. Use it strategically when the witness is clearly avoiding clarity.
5. Follow up: If the witness claims they cannot answer yes or no, press for specifics on why and address those directly.

Conclusion: Elevate Your Cross-Examination Skills

Controlling difficult witnesses is a vital skill for any trial attorney. Michael Waddington’s Kick-Ass Cross Exam Technique #8 provides a simple yet powerful tool to ensure you get clear, concise answers and maintain the upper hand during cross-examination. By asking, “Does something prevent you from answering yes or no?”, you can cut through evasiveness, clarify confusion, and strengthen your case.

Whether you are defending a serious criminal case, a military court-martial, or any litigation involving challenging witnesses, mastering this technique will enhance your courtroom effectiveness. For more expert legal insights and defense strategies from Michael and Alexandra Waddington, visit ucmjdefense.com or contact their Florida-based firm for a consultation.

Remember: The courtroom rewards preparation, precision, and control. Equip yourself with these skills and watch your trial performance soar.

If you found this post helpful, be sure to like and subscribe to the original video for more legal tips and trial techniques.

Full Transcription