Civilian military defense lawyers · Army · Navy · Air Force · Marine Corps · Coast Guard · Space Force · Worldwide Text 954-799-4019 Call 1-800-921-8607

Article 15 Lawyer | Military NJP Defense Attorney

Gonzalez & Waddington is a civilian military defense firm, founded by Michael Waddington and Alexandra Gonzalez-Waddington, that has defended service members at courts-martial and in UCMJ matters worldwide for more than two decades.

Talk to a lawyer before you accept or refuse an Article 15. The choice usually comes with a short deadline, and accepting nonjudicial punishment or demanding trial changes what can happen next. Gonzalez & Waddington, led by former Army JAG Michael Waddington, defends Army and Air Force Article 15s, Navy captain’s mast and Marine Corps office hours worldwide. Call 1-800-921-8607 or text 954-799-4019.

An Article 15 lawyer evaluates the evidence, the right to demand trial where it exists, the potential punishment, service-record consequences, and the risk that the same allegation may lead to court-martial or separation. Except for a member attached to or embarked in a vessel, Article 15 generally allows a service member to demand trial by court-martial before nonjudicial punishment is imposed. Accepting the Article 15 forum is ordinarily not an admission of guilt; it permits the commander to decide the allegation and punishment. Gonzalez & Waddington helps service members fight NJP in every branch, especially when rank, a clearance, a career or retirement is at stake.

The election should be evidence-driven. Demanding trial increases procedural protections and the government’s burden in a criminal forum, but it can also expose the member to far greater punishment and a criminal conviction. Accepting NJP may contain the immediate risk, yet reduction, forfeitures, a reprimand, filing decisions, evaluations, and later separation can still reshape a military career.

Governing authorityArticle 15, UCMJ, Part V of the current Manual for Courts-Martial, and the applicable service regulation.
Right to demand trialGenerally available before punishment, except for members attached to or embarked in a vessel and subject to governing regulations.
Accepting the forumOrdinarily does not admit guilt; the member can contest the allegation and present matters.
Proof and procedureThe commander decides under Part V and service rules; courtroom evidence rules do not apply in the same way as at a court-martial.
AppealArticle 15(e) allows appeal to the next superior authority when punishment is unjust or disproportionate.
Not a criminal convictionNJP is nonjudicial discipline, but its record can affect grade, pay, evaluations, promotion, reenlistment, clearance, and separation.

209 client reviews on Google and Avvo (as of November 2026). Read client testimonials.

What to do when you receive an Article 15

  • Do not sign the election blindly. Obtain the complete packet and understand the suspense.
  • Identify the vessel exception. Navy, Marine Corps, and Coast Guard members should verify whether they are attached to or embarked in a vessel.
  • Preserve evidence. Keep messages, videos, records, schedules, and witness information in original form.
  • Consult military defense counsel. Use TDS, ADC, DSO, or Coast Guard defense resources when eligible.
  • Compare both forums. Analyze admissibility, proof, maximum punishment, collateral consequences, and command posture.
  • Choose one coherent theory. Contest the allegation with evidence or present responsibility and mitigation without contradictory half-admissions.
  • Calendar appeal and filing deadlines. The case may continue after the hearing.
Video: Can a Civilian Lawyer Help Fight an Article 15, Captain’s Mast or NJP? (4:22) — watch on YouTube

What Article 15 and nonjudicial punishment actually mean

Article 15 of the UCMJ authorizes commanders to dispose of alleged minor misconduct without convening a court-martial. The services use different names—Article 15 in the Army, Air Force, and Space Force; captain’s mast in the Navy and Coast Guard; and office hours in the Marine Corps—but the statutory foundation is the same. The proceeding is nonjudicial: it is not a civilian criminal trial and the punishment is not itself a federal criminal conviction. It is still a formal exercise of command disciplinary authority with consequences that can reach well beyond the immediate punishment.

The governing rules are found in Article 15, 10 U.S.C. § 815, Part V of the current Manual for Courts-Martial, and service-specific regulations. Those authorities determine who may impose punishment, which punishments are available, whether the member may demand trial, how the hearing works, how the action is recorded, and how an appeal proceeds. The exact packet served on the member and the current service regulation must be reviewed before any election is signed.

Except for a member attached to or embarked in a vessel, Article 15 generally preserves the right to demand trial by court-martial before punishment is imposed.

10 U.S.C. § 815(a)

Accept the Article 15 forum or demand trial: the real calculation

Accepting an Article 15 does not ordinarily mean pleading guilty. It means allowing the commander to decide whether the alleged misconduct occurred and, if so, what punishment to impose. Demanding trial rejects the nonjudicial forum and forces the command to decide whether to drop the matter, use another administrative tool, or prefer court-martial charges. That election is often the most consequential decision in the case because it changes the decision-maker, procedures, potential punishment, evidentiary rules, and long-term risk.

The right answer cannot be derived from a slogan. A weak allegation may become substantially harder for the government when it must be proved in a criminal trial under the Military Rules of Evidence. A strong, well-documented allegation may expose the member to far greater consequences if the command proceeds to court-martial. The command’s charging appetite, the member’s record, the seriousness of the alleged conduct, the admissibility of statements and digital evidence, witness credibility, and the collateral consequences all belong in the calculation.

The vessel exception is especially important for Sailors, Marines, and Coast Guardsmen. Official Navy defense guidance explains that a person attached to or embarked in a vessel generally cannot refuse mast. Whether the exception applies can depend on assignment and status; do not assume that merely working near a ship answers the question. Review the actual circumstances and service guidance with counsel.

What proof does the commander use at an Article 15?

An Article 15 is not governed by every courtroom rule that applies at a general or special court-martial. The commander reviews the available evidence, hears the member’s presentation, and decides whether the alleged misconduct is established under the controlling Part V and service rules. Current Army public guidance describes the applicable finding standard as preponderance of the evidence following changes to the military-justice framework.

Even when the formal evidentiary rules are relaxed, evidence quality still matters. A sworn statement is not automatically reliable. A screenshot may lack context. A laboratory result may have collection or chain-of-custody issues. A witness may be repeating what someone else said. A digital extraction may show that a message existed without proving who sent it or what the surrounding conversation meant. The defense should assess the same questions a trial lawyer would ask: source, authenticity, completeness, credibility, contradiction, motive, and corroboration.

Evidence issueQuestions counsel should ask
Witness allegationWhat did the witness personally perceive? Has the account changed? What motive, bias, or memory issue exists?
Text or social-media evidenceIs the conversation complete? Who controlled the account? Are timestamps, metadata, deleted content, or other participants relevant?
Urinalysis or drug evidenceWas collection, handling, notification, laboratory testing, and knowing-use evidence examined?
Police or investigative reportDoes the report contain hearsay, conclusions, omitted interviews, or statements obtained after a rights advisement?
Video or photographWhat happened before and after the clip? Is the file authentic and complete? Does it prove intent?

The hearing is not a formality

A member who accepts the forum may contest the allegation, present documents, identify witnesses, make a statement or remain silent as permitted by the governing procedure, and present matters in defense, extenuation, and mitigation. Army Trial Defense Service guidance expressly notes that accepting the forum is not an admission and that a Soldier may present witnesses and other evidence. Service procedures differ concerning personal appearances, spokespersons, counsel participation, and the sequence of the hearing, so the packet should be treated as a litigation file rather than routine paperwork.

A strong presentation is organized around a clear theory. If the allegation is denied, every exhibit and witness should answer a disputed fact. If the conduct is admitted, the presentation should explain context, responsibility, rehabilitation, and why the proposed punishment or filing would be disproportionate. Mixing a factual denial with an apology that assumes guilt can undercut both positions. Counsel should decide which facts to concede, which to contest, and which questions should not be answered while a criminal investigation remains open.

Commanders do find members not guilty at NJP, and they also reduce, suspend, or tailor punishment after a focused mitigation presentation. The quality of the packet matters because the commander may have only a short period to absorb the evidence. A concise chronology, exhibit index, key witness statements, and a specific requested outcome are usually more persuasive than an emotional narrative without proof.

Article 15, mast, and office hours: service differences that matter

The UCMJ creates a common statutory base, but each service implements NJP through its own regulation and practice. An Army field-grade Article 15 has different reduction, filing, and career implications from an Air Force Article 15, a Marine office-hours case, or Navy captain’s mast. The imposing commander’s grade, the member’s grade, the vessel exception, reserve-component status, and the service’s filing rules can materially change the risk.

ServiceCommon termIssues to analyze
ArmyArticle 15Company-grade versus field-grade authority, potential reduction, DA Form 2627 filing, performance and separation consequences.
Air Force / Space ForceArticle 15DAF implementation, UIF and evaluation consequences, promotion impact, and parallel LOR or discharge action.
Navy / Coast GuardCaptain’s mastVessel exception, Booker consultation, service-record consequences, and appeal procedures.
Marine CorpsOffice hours / NJPVessel status, personal appearance, spokesperson practice, Page 11 or 6105 follow-on documentation, and separation risk.

The service label should never substitute for reading the actual notice. The member should identify the alleged UCMJ article, imposing commander, maximum available punishment, election deadline, supporting evidence, and whether the command has already initiated a flag, evaluation action, clearance action, or separation process.

Punishment is only one part of the risk

Article 15 permits different punishment ceilings depending on the commander and the member’s status. Potential consequences can include reduction, forfeiture or detention of pay, extra duties, restriction, correctional custody for eligible enlisted members, and reprimand. Officers face different statutory limits. The immediate punishment may be suspended, mitigated, remitted, or later set aside under Article 15(d), but none of those remedies should be assumed.

The longer shadow is often administrative. The action can affect evaluations, promotion, reenlistment, assignments, schools, special duties, security clearance, officer elimination, enlisted administrative separation, and retirement planning. A command may also use the same underlying conduct in a Letter of Reprimand, UIF, control roster, GOMOR, Page 11, 6105 counseling, or separation packet. Defense counsel should therefore build the Article 15 record as though a later board may read it.

If the member is already facing separation processing, review our Administrative Separation Board Lawyer guide. Army clients should also consider whether the same allegation could generate a GOMOR, while Airmen and Guardians should assess LOR and UIF exposure.

Appeals, suspension, mitigation, remission, and set-aside

Article 15(e) permits a member who believes the punishment is unjust or disproportionate to appeal through the proper channel to the next superior authority. The appeal is not simply a second opportunity to repeat the hearing statement. It should identify factual, legal, procedural, or proportionality errors and should be supported by the record. Larger punishments receive mandatory legal review before the appellate authority acts, as specified in the statute.

Separate from appeal, Article 15(d) authorizes specified command action to suspend, mitigate, remit, or set aside punishment and restore affected rights, privileges, and property. The standards and timing under service regulations matter. A set-aside request is strongest when it identifies a genuine injustice rather than merely asking for leniency after the fact. Counsel should preserve hearing materials, proof, and objections so later relief is not based on memory alone.

A prior NJP does not always bar a later court-martial for a serious offense arising from the same act. Article 15(f) addresses that circumstance and allows the prior punishment to be considered in sentencing if a later conviction occurs. That is another reason to obtain advice before making admissions or assuming the NJP will necessarily end the matter.

What a civilian Article 15 lawyer actually does

Counsel begins by obtaining the complete packet, calculating the deadline, identifying the maximum exposure, and separating the forum decision from the merits presentation. The lawyer evaluates the government’s evidence as if the case might become a court-martial, interviews or prepares witnesses where appropriate, develops the documentary record, and gives the client an honest risk assessment. If the member accepts the forum, counsel can help construct a focused presentation and prepare the member for questions. If punishment is imposed, counsel can evaluate appeal and collateral administrative action.

Military defense counsel should be consulted whenever available. Army TDS, Air Force ADC, Navy and Marine Corps Defense Service Offices, and Coast Guard defense counsel provide important independent advice. Whether retained civilian counsel adds value depends on the stakes, complexity, available preparation time, continuity needs, and whether the case is likely to expand into a court-martial or separation action. For a fuller comparison, see Civilian vs. JAG Defense Counsel.

The most useful lawyer is not the one who promises that demanding trial will scare the command. It is the lawyer who can explain what the evidence proves, what may be admissible at trial, what the maximum punishment is in each forum, how the service records the action, and how the decision affects the member’s career.

What our Article 15 representation includes, and what it costs

Article 15 representation at our firm generally starts at about $7,500, a flat fee quoted in writing before you sign. Here is what that fee covers. Military defense counsel can also help you at no cost.

Who does the work

Michael Waddington and Alexandra Gonzalez-Waddington advise you and write any rebuttal themselves. We do not hand it to an intern or an assistant, and we do not pass it to an outside lawyer and split the fee. We have been married since 1998, have practiced law together since 2006, and work every case together as a team.

Before the Article 15

Many clients come to us during the investigation, before any paperwork is served. We advise you through that stage, including what to say and what not to say.

When the Article 15 is offered

  • We review the evidence. We read the Article 15 paperwork and the evidence behind it, or help you get it if the command has not provided it.
  • We advise whether to accept it or demand a court-martial. Most service members can turn down an Article 15 and demand trial by court-martial, unless they are attached to or embarked on a vessel (Article 15, UCMJ, 10 U.S.C. § 815(a)). Either choice carries real risk, so make it with a lawyer.
  • We decide with you what to present. Sometimes the right move is to say nothing. In other cases we build a full packet: your statement, character letters, witness statements, and in some cases a legal memorandum arguing your case to the commander.
  • We help with the appeal. If you are found guilty, we can help you appeal to the next superior authority (10 U.S.C. § 815(e)).

Why what you say matters

Anything you say or submit at an Article 15 can be used against you later (Article 31, UCMJ, 10 U.S.C. § 831). A separation board or a show-cause board can also consider the Article 15 itself, so an admission made just to get through the hearing can follow you to that board. In many cases, the arguments should come from your lawyer, not from you.

Fees depend on the facts of each case. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Common Article 15 mistakes

  • Signing the election before reviewing the evidence. The decision may be irreversible once the deadline passes or punishment is imposed.
  • Assuming accepting Article 15 means admitting guilt. The member may accept the forum and contest the allegation.
  • Demanding trial as a bluff. The command may prefer charges, and the trial exposure can be dramatically greater.
  • Writing an emotional confession. A statement may be used in later criminal or administrative proceedings.
  • Submitting only character letters. Good duty performance does not resolve disputed facts when the allegation is contested.
  • Ignoring service-record consequences. Filing, evaluations, flags, UIFs, and separation may matter longer than extra duty.
  • Missing the appeal deadline. Begin evaluating appeal immediately after punishment is announced.
  • Deleting messages or contacting witnesses improperly. Preserve evidence and let counsel manage witness contact.

About Gonzalez & Waddington

Gonzalez & Waddington, LLC is a civilian military-defense law firm representing service members in serious UCMJ investigations, courts-martial, nonjudicial-punishment proceedings, reprimand rebuttals, administrative-separation cases, and officer boards worldwide. The firm is also known as UCMJ Defense Lawyers.

Michael Waddington

Michael Waddington is a former Army JAG prosecutor, Trial Defense Counsel, and Senior Defense Counsel with more than 25 years of military criminal-defense experience. He teaches trial advocacy as an adjunct law professor and is the author or co-author of books addressing cross-examination, closing argument, digital forensics, DNA, and serious criminal litigation. His practice focuses on high-stakes military investigations and contested trials.

Read Michael Waddington’s full biography.

Alexandra Gonzalez-Waddington

Alexandra Gonzalez-Waddington is a founding partner, former public defender, and civilian military-defense lawyer with more than two decades of criminal-defense experience. She has represented service members in serious courts-martial and administrative proceedings and has co-authored trial-advocacy and cross-examination books with Michael. She is fluent in English and Spanish.

Read Alexandra Gonzalez-Waddington’s full biography.

Experience is relevant, but it is not a guarantee of a particular result. A useful consultation should address the actual allegation, evidence, deadlines, forum, service-specific procedure, and the work counsel would perform.

For a step-by-step explanation of the Article 15 process, your rights, filing, and appeals, read our complete Article 15 guide.

Video transcript

The video above is “Can a Civilian Lawyer Help Fight an Article 15, Captain’s Mast or NJP?” from Gonzalez & Waddington. Read the full transcript on our guide to hiring a civilian lawyer for nonjudicial punishment.

GOMOR vs. Article 15 vs. court-martial: how they compare

A GOMOR, an Article 15 and a court-martial are three different actions. Each has its own rules, its own rights and its own way to fight back. This table shows the main differences for an Army soldier.

GOMOR (Army reprimand)Article 15 (nonjudicial punishment)Court-martial
What it isAn administrative written reprimand, usually from a general officer (AR 600-37)Punishment imposed by your commander without a trial (Article 15, UCMJ, 10 U.S.C. § 815)A criminal trial under the UCMJ: summary, special or general (Article 16, 10 U.S.C. § 816)
Can you turn it down?No. You can submit a rebuttal before the general officer decides where to file it (AR 600-37).Yes. You can demand trial by court-martial instead, unless you are attached to or embarked in a vessel (§ 815(a)).No. You can plead not guilty and contest the charges at trial.
Possible punishmentNone by itself. The harm comes from where it is filed and who sees it.Limited by statute. For enlisted members, a field-grade Article 15 can include reduction in grade (a member above E-4 can be reduced no more than two grades), forfeiture of half a month’s pay for two months, 45 days of extra duty and 60 days of restriction (§ 815(b)).Depending on the type of court and the offense, can include confinement and a punitive discharge (R.C.M. 1003).
Where it goes in your recordFiled locally or in your Army Military Human Resource Record (AMHRR), where promotion, school and retention boards see it (AR 600-37).A record of the proceedings, filed according to your service’s rules.A record of trial and any conviction.
How to challenge it afterwardAppeal to the Department of the Army Suitability Evaluation Board (DASEB) to remove it or move it to the restricted folder (AR 600-37, chapter 7).Appeal to the next superior authority if the punishment is unjust or disproportionate (§ 815(e)).Post-trial review and, in qualifying cases, appeal to the service Court of Criminal Appeals (Article 66, 10 U.S.C. § 866).
Your right to a lawyerYou can consult free military defense counsel or hire a civilian lawyer.You can consult a lawyer before deciding whether to accept it or demand trial (AR 27-10).Free detailed military defense counsel, plus the right to civilian counsel you hire (Article 38(b), 10 U.S.C. § 838).
Can it lead to something worse?Yes. A filed GOMOR can support a separation or elimination action (AR 635-200; officers, AR 600-8-24).Yes. Accepting an Article 15 does not bar a later court-martial for a serious offense from the same conduct (§ 815(f)), and it can support separation.A conviction can bring confinement, a punitive discharge and lasting civilian consequences.

For a fuller side-by-side, see GOMOR vs. Article 15 vs. court-martial: which is worse for your career? Gonzalez & Waddington defends soldiers in all three. Call 1-800-921-8607 or text 954-799-4019 for a free consultation.

Where we defend: Gonzalez & Waddington represents service members facing Article 15 and NJP at installations worldwide, including Fort Bragg, Fort Hood, Beale AFB, Camp Pendleton, Naval Base San Diego and Germany. See the full list of bases we serve.

Turning down an Article 15 only works if your lawyer can win at trial

Most service members (except those attached to or embarked on a vessel) can refuse nonjudicial punishment and demand trial by court-martial. That right is only as strong as the lawyer behind it. Consider a fictional E-6 offered an Article 15 for an alleged assault at an off-post bar, with video that is unclear. If his lawyer has tried many contested cases, refusing the Article 15 is a real option, and commands often reconsider when they know the case will be tested. If his lawyer rarely goes to trial, the refusal is a bluff, and the command may know it.

What Gonzalez & Waddington brings: Michael Waddington has tried more than 200 contested trials and teaches trial skills to other defense lawyers at NACDL conferences and the National Trial Lawyers Summit. He is a Fellow of the American Board of Criminal Lawyers, an invitation-only organization of trial lawyers.

For the full list of factors, see how to find the best court-martial lawyer for your case: 18 factors that matter.

Frequently asked questions

Can a civilian lawyer help me fight nonjudicial punishment?

Yes. A civilian lawyer can advise you before you decide whether to accept the Article 15 or demand trial by court-martial, help gather evidence and witness statements, prepare your presentation to the commander, and draft your appeal. Whether a lawyer can speak for you at the hearing itself depends on your service and the type of proceeding, and civilian counsel is at your own expense. If you are attached to or embarked on a vessel, you cannot refuse NJP, which makes early advice even more important.

Is an Article 15 a federal conviction?

No. Article 15 is nonjudicial punishment, not a conviction by a criminal court. It can nevertheless create serious military personnel and career consequences.

Can I refuse an Article 15?

Except for members attached to or embarked in a vessel, Article 15 generally permits a member to demand trial by court-martial before punishment. Service regulations and the facts control.

Does accepting Article 15 mean I am guilty?

Ordinarily no. Accepting the forum allows the commander to decide guilt and punishment; the member may contest the allegation and present evidence.

Can a lawyer appear at the Article 15 hearing?

There is no uniform statutory right to counsel physically participating at every NJP hearing. Service rules vary. Counsel can still advise, prepare the presentation, and evaluate the election and appeal.

What happens if I demand trial?

The command may drop the matter, use administrative action, or prefer court-martial charges. A demand does not guarantee trial or dismissal.

Can an Article 15 lead to administrative separation?

Yes. The underlying conduct and the NJP record may support later separation, officer elimination, adverse evaluation, or other personnel action.

How long do I have to appeal?

The deadline is short and service-specific. Read the punishment document and consult counsel immediately rather than relying on a general internet rule.

Can punishment be suspended or set aside?

Article 15(d) authorizes specified command relief including suspension, mitigation, remission, and set-aside. The governing service rule and facts determine whether relief is appropriate.

Should I write an apology?

Only after deciding the defense theory. An apology can support mitigation but may also function as an admission in later proceedings.

How much does an Article 15 lawyer cost?

Fees depend on the record, deadline, investigation, hearing scope, witnesses, and whether the case overlaps with court-martial or separation. Ask for a written scope and flat or staged fee where appropriate.

Should I hire a civilian lawyer before accepting an Article 15?

Talk to a lawyer before you decide. You can consult a military defense lawyer (Trial Defense Service, Defense Service Office or Area Defense Counsel) at no cost. A civilian lawyer you hire can add time, an independent look at the evidence and a stronger written presentation, which matters most when your rank, career or retirement is at stake, when the same allegation could also lead to separation, or when you are weighing whether to demand trial. See Should I hire a lawyer before accepting an Article 15?

What should I look for in an Article 15 or NJP lawyer?

Look for a lawyer who regularly handles nonjudicial punishment and courts-martial in your branch, who will personally work on your case before your deadline, who explains the accept-or-demand-trial decision in plain terms, and who puts the fee and scope in writing. Ask who will draft your written matters and who will attend the hearing with you as your spokesperson.

Can a civilian lawyer help with Navy captain’s mast or Marine Corps office hours?

Yes. Sailors and Marines face nonjudicial punishment under the same Article 15, called captain’s mast or office hours. A lawyer can advise you before you decide, help you prepare evidence, witnesses and a written statement, act as your spokesperson at the hearing where that is allowed, and prepare your appeal. Navy and Marine Corps NJP appeals are generally due within 5 working days, and members attached to or embarked in a vessel generally cannot refuse NJP. See how to appeal NJP in the Navy and Marine Corps.

Will an Article 15 end my military career?

Not necessarily. Many service members recover from a single Article 15, but it can affect promotion, schools, reenlistment and security clearance decisions, and it can be used to support administrative separation. How you respond, and in the Army where the record is filed, both matter. See Will an Article 15 end my military career?

Sources and authorities

  1. Article 15, UCMJ — commanding officer’s nonjudicial punishment.
  2. Current Manual for Courts-Martial and updates — Joint Service Committee; consult Part V.
  3. Army Trial Defense Service — Article 15 and defense guidance.
  4. Navy Defense Service Office — NJP rights and vessel exception.

Discuss the situation with a civilian military defense lawyer

If you are facing this issue, identify the next irreversible decision and the earliest deadline. Gonzalez & Waddington offers confidential consultations to service members and families dealing with serious military investigations, adverse actions, and courts-martial in the United States and overseas.

Call 1-800-921-8607 or text 954-799-4019 to request a consultation.

Legal-information notice: This page provides general educational information and is not legal advice for any person or case. Military law, executive orders, service regulations, and local procedures change. The facts, status, component, location, and governing version of each authority matter. Reading this page or contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Video transcript: Can a Civilian Lawyer Help Fight an Article 15, Captain’s Mast or NJP?

Transcript of the video “Can a Civilian Lawyer Help Fight an Article 15, Captain’s Mast or NJP?,” with Alexandra Gonzalez-Waddington of Gonzalez & Waddington.

Read the full transcript of this video

Can a civilian lawyer help you fight non-judicial punishment? Yes. You don’t have a right to a lawyer in the room at most NJP hearings, but nothing stops a civilian lawyer from building your case. And the case is built before you walk in.

I’m Alexandra Gonzalez-Waddington, civilian military defense lawyer and co-founder of Gonzalez & Waddington. People assume that because NJP is non-judicial, lawyers don’t matter. The opposite is true. Because there’s no judge and no rules of evidence, preparation is the only protection you have.

Here’s what a civilian lawyer actually does. First, the rules on representation because they vary by service. In the Army, you can consult with counsel before deciding to accept the Article 15. And at the hearing, you can have a spokesperson who can be a lawyer.

The commander controls how much the spokesperson can do. In the Navy and Marine Corps, you can consult counsel before mast and have a personal representative at mast who can be a lawyer if the CO permits. In the Air Force, you consult with the area defense counsel and submit a written response. The hearing is usually a meeting with the commander.

In the Coast Guard, similar. In none of them is a lawyer guaranteed a speaking role. In all of them, the lawyer’s work happens before the hearing. Here’s what that work is.

One, reading the evidence. Before you accept NJP, before you write a word, a lawyer reads the sworn statements, the test results, the video, and tells you what the government actually has. That informs everything else, including whether to refuse. Two, the accept or refuse decision.

Covered in its own video, but this is where a lawyer who knows your installation’s habits pays for themselves. Three, the written response. This is the heart of NJP defense. Under every service’s rules, you can present matters in your defense before the commander decides.

A lawyer builds it. A statement that explains without confessing, exhibits that corroborate, character letters from people the commander respects, your evaluations, your awards, evidence of what you’ve done since. The commander reads it before the hearing. A well-built packet changes the commander’s mind about guilt, about punishment, or about filing.

Four, the hearing script. What you’ll say, what you won’t, how you’ll answer the questions the commander is likely to ask. Most people at NJP talk themselves into the maximum. A prepared client doesn’t.

Five, the witnesses. If you have a witness who helps, a lawyer identifies them, gets a statement, and makes sure they’re available, because reasonably available is the standard, and the command decides. Six, the filing fight. For senior enlisted in the Army, the permanent versus restricted filing is the whole ballgame, and the response argues it explicitly.

Seven, the appeal. Within 5 days to the next superior. The appeal argues that the punishment was unjust or disproportionate on the record you made. A lawyer writes it.

Eight, what comes next? NJP is often step one in a separation. A lawyer who handles the NJP is already positioned for the board. What it costs.

A flat fee, a fraction of a court-martial, and cheap next to a reduction in grade for a senior NCO or a lost retirement. At Gonzalez & Waddington, some of the most career-saving work we do is NJP responses nobody outside the command ever sees. So, can a civilian lawyer help you fight NJP? Yes, before the hearing, where it counts.

The evidence, the decision, the response, the script, the filing, and the appeal. I’m Alexandra Gonzalez-Waddington with Gonzalez & Waddington. We defend service members worldwide. You can learn more at ucmjdefense.com or call 1-800-921-8607 for a free confidential consultation.

Call now Text us Message